The Russian Revolution and the French Revolution were unique in their ways, the two Revolutions were fought by the people of each country to liberate themselves of the tyrannical regime that oppressed them and the results of the French and the Russian revolution were the ousting of the government of the two countries of that time. Very similar to Russia, one of the causes of the French Revolution was that the economy was struggling dramatically especially with produce. He accuses people of doing actions he himself has done. The main difference between the two revolutions is that the Napoleon Bonaparte was born on a small island in the Mediterranean Sea, to a family of minor nobility. The Palace, Versailles, was built by king Louis XIV and the expenses for building this village was very high, and in later years the cost for its upkeep would play a significant role in Frances financial difficulties. The October Revolution was a revolution against the provisional government by the Bolsheviks who made the country the first communist state (Pipes 42-49). The Czar response to this revolution was not promising. politics. One such innovation is mammography., The choice of topic for this paper results from the case of leukemia in my family. Any opinions, findings, conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of UKEssays.com. The French Revolution and the American Revolution, had many similarities and differences. Although both revolutions had a lot in common, they had differences as well. The similarities are that the French leader, Louis XVI, and the Russian leader, Nicholas II were both rulers who didn't really want to be the ones in charge. This essentially caused certain insecurity among the peasant population throughout the Russian Empire. These personalities changes the image of the world forever and lead to the appearance of some unique phenomena which predetermine further development of society and the whole world. Beginning in 1789 with the French Revolution and ending, Sheila Fitzpatrick is a highly esteemed scholar who has been publishing and editing works on Russian history since the 1970s ("Sheila Fitzpatrick, Latin Christendom is one of the most important times in history, and a study of this period can reveal some interesting conclusions, Owing to the rising outcry of patients with cancer and their demand for attention, it is important to sort an integrative medical, There are a wide range of technological innovations that have fundamentally altered the field of health care. In Russia, The proletariat, or the working class, fought for equal rights. Wilhelm was at fault for the start of World War I. WebIn addition, French Republicanism introduced an element of radical egalitarianism that sets it apart from the other two revolutions, and the French Revolution was far more radically Russian revolution, on the other hand, had communist values and occurred due to collapse of government from the top. The country became united and a very powerful country that for a time was prospering. - Resulted in mass murders. WebDespite the fact that French and Russian revolutions occurred over a century apart, both revolutions had two major similarities: poor economy and bad leadership. They both support the idea of everyone being able to live another persons life in the sense that someone poor could still receive the education that a wealthy person gets. Maximillien Robespierre the leader of the Reign of Terror in the French Revolution. The similarities between the Glorious and French Revolutions is that they are both successful revolutions This made the people despise not only the king, but the queen too because they both were spending money on clothes and. In an article written by the Britannica called French Revolution 1787-1789, the authors write Thepeasants had attained an improved standard of livingand wanted to get rid of feudalismso as to acquire the full rights of landowners and to be free to increase their holdings. This illuminates what the people were feeling and why the revolution occurred in the first place. Toussaint Louverture played three major roles in the Haitian Revolution. It may be hard to determine the main reasons for the Revolution, but the spark can be narrowed down to three main reasons. The French Revolution did not stop there. Thus, having plunge France into a chain of wars, Napoleon turned into the tyrant, which contradicted to the ideas of revolution. This was Frances workforce. What are the differences and similarities between the French Revolution and the Russian Revolution? The philosophs were not directly responsible for the outbreak but they sparked that change of thought into action Doc 5. WebBoth the French Revolution of the late 18th century and the Russian Revolution of the early 20th century share a few similarities. The main difference between the Bourgeoisie and the others in the third estate was that the Bourgeoisies were educated, specifically in enlightenment ideas. The French revolution was a direct cause of the excess of the ruling classes, while the American revolution was in response to the high taxes imposed on them by Russian revolution, on the other hand, had communist values and occurred due to collapse of government from the top. There was an overwhelming want in the proletariat class, as they were living in desperate need constantly. Russian Revolution, also called Russian Revolution of 1917, two revolutions in 1917, the first of which, in February (March, New Style), overthrew the The similarities are that the French leader, Louis XVI, and the The heavy price for walking away was felt by the entire masses of Russia. (eBook and Paperback). While French revolution around 1789. Name Instructor Date Empress Elizabeth impact on, This has been studied in context of the book by Charles Tilly titled European Revolutions (1993) The hypothesis of this paper is the study of similarities and differences between UK, France and Russia as far as the aspects of the journey from, In 1898, he left his native Bialystok for Ukraine to become an active member of, The essay "French Revolution in International Relations Theory" focuses on the analysis of the key approaches of realism, liberalism, and critical theory to provide an in-depth understanding of, Let us write or edit the essay on your topic, "A Comparison between the Russian and the French Revolution", 3 (750 words), compare and contrast french and american revolution, Maksim Litvinov and Soviet Foreign Policy during the 1930s, The French Revolution and the Cultural Renewal of Europe, To What Extent Did Ivan Vyshnegradsky and Sergei Witte Industrialize 19thcentury Russia, French Revolution in International Relations Theory, A Comparison between the Russian and the French Revolution. They had their similarities, their differences, and their differences in similarities. Webwhose works on the French Revolution have helped me to gain new insights into the Russian Revolution. The French Revolution and the Russian Revolution have an astronomical amount of similarities. For example, The Essay Writing ExpertsUK Essay Experts. Since the people cannot get their necessities, the people would cause riots by forming a government of their own. The causes for the Russian Revolution of 1917 were very similar to that of the 18th century revolution that took place in France. The comparison of causes between these two revolutions were very much alike, the causes were almost identical. The ideas of the Enlightenment thinkers brought new views of government and society. What is are the functions of diverse organisms? The most important long-range causes of this revolution, however, were the ideas of the Enlightenment, the unfair taxes, the gap between the rich and poor, and the American Revolution, The American and French revolutions both compare and contrast in their origins and outcomes; both revolutions began due to the common peoples need to obtain independence and liberty from an oppressive government. If your specific country is not listed, please select the UK version of the site, as this is best suited to international visitors. The people began to support the Bolshevik party and agree with their campaign. Revolution was the only way average people or citizens felt they can challenge and fight the ultimate power. Napoleon lived as another did continuing a cycle of viciousness while Huss created a new way of life proving that when people conform the past repeats itself and when you do not conform you create a new way of life and a change of. When the Ottoman Empire joined the Central Powers in World War I; it blocked off key trade routes to the Russians. In Iran, the Shah used a similar method of aloof leadership; he made ties with the West and tried to industrialize Iran. "Compare the French Revolution and the Russian Revolution." The French Revolution took place during the latter half of the 18th century. People began to recognize that Czar Nicholas II autocracy government was harming the political, economical, and cultural will of the people of Russia. The French were driven by envy, mob violence, freedom (associated with license), anti-Christian sentiment and entitlement. The Soviet Union was quickly formed, and when the first leader of this new country, Vladimir Lenin, became ill, Stalin was quick to step up and obtain more power (Workers Liberty)., The crumbling army, food shortages, numerous uprisings, and taking away peoples right of speech and press in the proletariat class lead to a very successful February Revolution in 1917(Jerry and Ziegler, 1). Compared to the antics of the French Revolution, the infamous Tea Party in Boston was like the sisters at the convent sneaking into the dorm of the rival convent and shorting their sheets. But broad similarities do emerge. He changed the way millions of people thought and worshipped and in death sparked an entire revolution and branch or religion known as protestantism. controls all resources and there is no private property in eNotes Editorial, 24 July 2019, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/compare-french-revolution-russian-revolution-from-343206. The peasant class had a role in the revolution due to the fact that most did not want to be farmers any more. They seized governmental and public buildings. It questioned the authority of kings, priests, and nobles. They adapted an assembly which was called the State Duma of the Russian Empire which limited the power of Czar Nicholas II but he still retained his hierarchy in a set of his own laws which he issued himself called the Fundamental Laws. The lack in of capital, as well as the rise of Great Britain was another economic cause of the revolution. With the British having a very strict authority over the Americans, this made them rebel and feel deserving of freedom, establishment of their own people, and that taxes shouldn't go to The United Kingdom. After 8 years of war, Britain had to give up on their American colonies because they overtaxed their citizens., The struggle between classes and the corruption of the government are problems that have existed for 100s of years. A revolution is not an event that comes around every few years. Stimulating money for the economy proved too difficult to overcome and like the Russians, the revolutionary step was inevitable. Which was a key point in this revolution; it was at this time that the Roman Catholic Church started to lose its power to the people. Both revolutions eventually got more radical and violent, the French Revolution with the Reign of Terror where citizens were guillotined, while the Russian Revolution had Bloody Sunday, where citizens were killed. Due to the Bolsheviks tyrannical leadership the masses rights to freedom were taken away and education began to fail; furthermore, there was no longer a freedom to religions. The Russian Revolution was a series of two revolutions that consisted of the February Revolution and the October Revolution. Others may argue that since Tsar was an unproductive leader and because of the decisions he made when he was in power that influenced the Russian Revolution. From simple essay plans, through to full dissertations, you can guarantee we have a service perfectly matched to your needs. Humans have been evolving since then trying their level best to survive and trying to nurture themselves in this hostile environment.All of these revolutions have impacted the lives of people and have changed As Putin continues killing civilians, bombing kindergartens, and threatening WWIII, Ukraine fights for the world's peaceful future. They people never liked Louis and Nicholas because of things like Comparing the French and Russian Revolutions of 1917, Book Review: The Russian Revolution by Sheila Fitzpatrick. Each person is a prisoner of their own social background, willingly or unwillingly. The aftermath of the Russian Revolution would forever be felt throughout the world. Compare the French and the Russian Revolutions. Poor In the search of equality, these two revolutions used different ideals of equality. Who is Katy mixon body double eastbound and down season 1 finale? These people were fairly well off and had a bit of extra money. In an article on the Princeton University Press titled The Furies: Violence and Terror in the French and Russian Revolutions written by author Arno J. Mayer, it describes the revolutions similarities Both revolutions began as revolts vowed to fight unreason, injustice, and inequality; both swept away old regimes and defied established religions in societies that were 85% peasant and illiterate Both countries were not acting responsibly, and the leadership taking place left much to be desired. Up until 1792, Louis XVI was reigning in France. As it was the Bolsheviks led the country further into communism. The current leadership fled for safety and the Bolsheviks were effectively put into power. He was incredibly ambitious, courageous, and possessed no fear. This governmental collapse was not the only cause of the Russian Revolution of 1917; the First World War also had a major impact economically instead of politically. In 1855-1881 Alexander II reigned and during his time he emancipated the serfs of Russia in 1861. Both revolutions were tremendously committed to achieve freedom and equality amongst all the people of both nations. Both were very famous political gures known for dealing with civil wars amongst their countries. This movement towards the establishment of a constitutional government influenced political thought throughout the world. No matter what reforms were made, revolutions tend to have very similar causes such as unfairness between government and citizens, social inequality, and other revolutions and documents declaring independence, rights, or reform. Both revolutions were successful in overthrowing the monarchy, however, the years after the revolution demonstrate which was the more successful. Finally, their solutions werent solutions at all, yet, France had three estates- the lowest being the poorest and 98% of the population. However, many Europeans viewed the Revolution as much more than just a bloody massacre. WebThe French Revolution and the Russian Revolution have an astronomical amount of similarities. These are the social and economic similarities. Socially, France had divided its population within 3 estates (classes). Although Tsars weak leadership may have influenced the Russian Revolution, World War I was the main cause of the Russian Revolution because it destroyed the economy, which led to riots and many people, The main causes were the poverty of the peasant class, the rise of the urban industrial class, and the inefficiency the Tsarist regime. The first main reason is the negligence of the king to the civilians and the second is the under-representation of the Third Estate and over taxation, lack of food and the economic hardships. Bonaparte had demands for a second presidential term and money from the conservative majority that lead to the build up to the coup., The change from being Monarchy to Communism to modern day Russia and the drastic change in the Economy has affected Russia dramatically. The similarities of the American Revolution and the French revolution can be seen by examining the root causes, the rebels, and the lasting impact of both revolutions. Webassessment of the Russian situation in the RussoJapanese War and the First World War is less so. Both entered bloody phases as radical forces (the Bolsheviks in Russia and the Jacobins, backed by urban radicals in France) emerged to gain control. There was endless struggles between the left wing and the right wing during the French revolution. The government had a very high tax rate on the poorest of their people, the Third Estate, and they were still not getting enough money to get out of their, The final group of the Old Regime was the third estate. Although they are in different parts of the world, they are often heavily compared to each other. The primary cause of the revolution was the disputes over. Both of these countries had different The French and Russian revolutions had some very similar characteristics that created drastic unrest from the people. The French decided towards a democracy while the Russian government became communist . Although he did not belong within the French military, Napoleon believed that he was simply destined for grandeur accomplishments. The Russian revolution of 1917 was a dual revolution that happened in a single year, while the French revolution was a single revolution that lasted for about ten years. The conflicts, which started as protests and demonstrations, quickly turned violent, leading to the execution of many in the ruling classes. Bonaparte created a unicameral legislature and universal male suffrage during his time as president undermining the wishes of the other social classes within the government. (1) The leaders in power before the revolutions favored changing the political system in their country. The second similarity is that both revolutions led The February Revolution of March 8th, 1917 was a revolution targeted and successfully removed Czar Nicholas II from power. But we are concerned here with something else, One of the differences is that Russia was in industrialization, as Marx observed the inequality of the people. The third estate had sub-groups of its own. WebAnswer: Thats an interesting question Lets start with the differences 1st okay. Although both revolutions had a lot in common, they had differences as well. Similarities and differences. The French Revolution didnt happen overnight but happened due to a series of events. Both Toussaint LOuverture and Napoleon Bonaparte led according to their beliefs and upbringings Napoleon and Toussaint were wildly similar due to their beliefs. Unlike the The similarity between them is that the citizens in both countries, both faced the block of common economical development of the government. Lenin becomes the chairman of the new communist government which marks the end of the Russian Revolution of 1917. In August 1917, Kornilov, a Russian general, had tried to steal the power from The Soviets with the Provisional Governments support. This revolution was inspired by the Americans who fought against Britains rule and overcame that government (document 5). - Inspired by other Revelations. The rise of the industrial class went hand in hand with the peasant class as the industrial class more or less controlled the peasant class who had no choice but to get jobs at the big industries. What did the Gilded Age reformers have in common with Jackson era reformers? Napolean used dogs, Moses, and Squealor to control the animals. The Reign of Terror also played a key role in the French Revolution. This lead to an inflation of money and the peasants grew angrier because of the high prices of items such as food and also the increase in food shortages. It was rather the result of the accumulation of many events spread all through the 18th century. WebVery similar to Russia, one of the causes of the French Revolution was that the economy was struggling dramatically especially with produce. Britain needed the colonies for financial support, they had been at war with France for thirty years, Britains treasury was in need of funds. Each powerful leader has their strengths, weaknesses, and downfalls. Use your promo and get a custom paper on Comparing the French and Russian Revolutions of 1917. While there have been numerous revolutions throughout the course of history, the two most arguably prominent revolutions remain to be the American Revolution and the French He became the hero of the French Revolution, a person who was excepted to change the image of France providing liberation and equality for its citizens. The situation just got worst because there was a conflict of ideas between the three classes, especially a clash between the upper two classes and the bottom class and therefore they could not successfully come to terms with each other. However, their efforts were at too small a scale to have any real effect. What are the Differences and similarities between power and Both countries had a monarchy with a ruler that could not properly assist his people, specifically the classes that were heavily taxed on. They deserved better from those in leadership. Both men lost their campaigns in Russia. Let's start with differences first. King Kamehameha was the man who conquered and united all of the Hawaiian islands. The first group was the Bourgeoisie. He decided to let his mother and other relatives to take control over governmental affairs., Theyre simply waiting for an eager tyrant to benefit from their lack of education. The hens were the only ones to rebel against him but died not long after their food supply had been cut off. This was a tradition that had been upheld through the years and the Royal family had enjoyed a life funded by the people of France, the royal familys lifestyle unaffected by the situation outside their palace. However, through deeper understanding of their personalities and true motivations, similarities start unearthing, Some similarities between France and the U.S. are their history. Essay The French and Russian Revolutions were as similar and different as any given two people. The major similarity they both shared were that the In both revolutions, the When the Tsar refused to reform to his peoples needs, he was eventually executed and led to the rise of, Similarities Between French Revolution And Russian Revolution. This clash of opposites created an unavoidable civil war between the two groups. Accessed May 01, 2016. http://academic.mu.edu/meissnerd/russian-rev.htm. In an article on the Academica.mu.eud titled The Russian Revolution of 1917, the author says the government tried to help by passing factory acts to restrict the amount of hours one could work. This led to great discontent with the ruling classes. Lincoln was a supporter of stopping the expansion of slavery which won him the popularity of the northern states. French Revolution resulted in a democratic government and the both wanted equality from the king and to be treated well. However, he still dreaded of equality and prosperity of France, trying to protect it and guarantee its leading role in the world policy, in order to use its influence and spread the ideas of revolution. Radical leaders eventually got control over the government, such as Robespierre with the Committee of Public Safety and they issued their own policies Then, the Russian Revolution eventually ended with the Soviet Union taking control of Russia, similar to how Napoleon took control of France in the French Revolution. The people were aiming to start a constitution to possibly end the revolution, but the constitution failed much like Russian Duma because it was a sharing of power between the King and Assembly which caused them to be at odds with each other. The French revolution was deeply rooted in the ideals of Enlightenment and involved the overthrow of the monarchy. Similar, to how the French Revolution started due to the heavy tax burden placed on the Third Estate. But the peasants also served as a conservative force as Parisian radicals enacted price restrictions on grain and especially measures aimed at weakening the Catholic Church such as the Civil Constitution of the Clergy. This was refreshing and the masses in Russia revolted and allowed the Bolsheviks to seize power and crush leadership in control of the Russian people. This was a direct effect of the poor governmental system that the French had. Also, he was staging plays while the country was 40 billion dollars in debt. Russian Revelotion Various causes - Absolute Monarchy - The first Revelation - World War 1 - Marxism - Rasputin Instead of stages, various small revolutions - February Revolution - October Manifesto Led to the creation of the soviet union French 1. WebThe German Revolution of 1918-1919 did not resemble a real revolution, leastwise not in the traditional sense of the French Revolution of 1789 and the Russian Revolution of 1917, or even the German Revolution of 1848 (Bassel, 1993). The Russian Revolution of 1917. The Russian Revolution of 1917. WebDifferences A difference between the two revolutions is that the Russians had an unsuccessful "pre-revolution" in 1905. Mostly, because many were in debt and couldnt pay it off so they sought out better jobs in the big cities but consequently they were given minimal pay, awful living conditions, and little to no rights as workers. World War I began in 1914. First came the American Revolution: the movement that formed the United States. The ideals expressed by the Bolsheviks was equality, peace, property, and food. (2) economic success of mercantilism. But again this system was not perfect; it sprang into a Dual power between two main factions the Bolsheviks or Lenins communist (Red), and the Anit-Bolsheviks (white) which was composed of the groups who were against communism such as the imperialist, conservatives, and nationalist. Throughout history there have been some very noteworthy revolutions such as the Agricultural Revolution, the American Revolution, and the French Revolution. Latest answer posted October 06, 2019 at 11:40:56 AM. Both the French Revolution of the late 18th century and the Russian Revolution of the early 20th century share a few similarities. The Russian Revolution happened much later in history but its causes were very similar to the French Revolution. Otto Von Bismarck was commonly known as the best hated man in the country by his people (Tucker). Therefore, both lower class groups took to revolution. The French and American Revolutions were the instances of civilians rebelling against their government. Tsar Nicholas of the Soviet Union was in huge debt after World War I (Pipes), while the French Monarch had mismanaged the finances of France (Feher). Another commonality that they share is their view on equal opportunities for all (Handout #1). financial decisions, putting the townspeople into economic crises. Revolutions are a common occurrence throughout world history. These people made up ninety-seven percent of the population, but were only allotted seventy percent of the land. Communism triumphed in China in 1949, 30 years after the Russian Revolution. Political, social, and economic conditions in France mad many French people discontented. Copyright 2003 - 2023 - UKEssays is a trading name of Business Bliss Consultants FZE, a company registered in United Arab Emirates. Many people had their natural rights renounced and werent able to have a political voice. It was very harsh and would lead only further downhill. (2) Both revolutions were the result of government denial of basic Both countries had a monarchy with a ruler that could not properly assist his people, specifically the classes that were heavily taxed on. The outcomes for these two nations after their revolution were ultimately very opposite of each other. (4) bring radicals to power. Both the Russian and French revolutions involved so many complex events that attempting to draw parallels will inevitably lead to oversimplification. Although there were some differences in both revolutions, they were still very much alike. Already a member? The poor became poorer, King Louis XVI lost power, and hundreds of thousands of people would end up losing their lives. If a group or a certain leader of the country doesnt meet the needs of their citizens, the people would rise to take over to reach their necessities. Here you can choose which regional hub you wish to view, providing you with the most relevant information we have for your specific region. During the late 18th century, America a country ruled by The United Kingdom, had no control of the thirteen colonies. WebMany lesser nobles and pro-government generals were killed in purges during the French Revolution and Russian Revolution. This violence was shared between the two, as beheading and poisoning were common. The revolutions of the American Colonies, France and Latin America had a common thread in that they wanted free from rule by a corrupt government. This is considered a major turning point in European history which has led to dramatic changes in France and other regions of the world.
No comments.