There may be means to report harrassnent, bullying, and abuse in figure skating, but is it really followed up fast, is there any ignorance built into the organization? He reported to the US Center for Safesport that he was sexually abused and assaulted by Callaghan in 1976 when he was a young skater of only 13 years old. MOSCOW, February 9. It gets even more serious and goes beyond bullying and abuse for figure skaters. I dreaded going to practice, wished for car accidents and sobbed through entire training sessions. It was better to say nothing, she told the outlet. She shared this resonating quote: There was a point in my life when the abuse made me hate the sport. Say anything and you have lost your promising career, so many skaters like Jessica have held this in, until recently. dailybulletin.com - Scott M. Reid 1d. The person is humiliated by whispering, gossiping, and blanking even when the person is sitting next to you. Perhaps this has been the predominant fertilizer for the dark shadows growing behind the aesthetic grandeur of the sport. Americas own Gracie Gold came forward to the New York Times last year with her own version of this story. One of the jumps that takes a lot of mettle to even attempt is the triple axel. After many years of suffering from this abuse, Yu decided to come forward and speak out about what many young figure skaters in China have to face. Proper funding channels need to be established to sustain such organisations because their nature of work naturally invites backlash. The IOC safeguarding team is in regular contact with national Olympic committees, to offer advice and support, including highlighting the available IOC initiatives such as the IOC athlete safeguarding toolkit; safe sport educational tools and materials, and initiatives to protect athletes at the Olympic Games and Youth Olympic Games., Human Rights Watch criticises Japan after report reveals abuse of athletes, Gymnastics coaches being investigated will be banned from Team GB, says BOA, Athlete A review the scandal that rocked the sporting world. This comment, coupled with compliments about how good she looked after dropping a few pounds and her ability to fly faster across the ice, drove Gold to a diet of just one tomato and several cups of coffee per day. Governments, as well as corporations could provide aid. Figure Skating Hall of Fame, and Silvia Fontana, a 2002 and 2006 Olympian representing . The slow procedure and high bureaucracy of ISU; and the indifferent responses authorities have given till now, necessitate individual nations to take steps to protect their athletes. Thus, the need to protect young female skaters is pressing. I composed this article, to try and push the Figure Skating side of the story, since the recent UK gymnastics scandal has taken the news across National TV stations. Katarina Witt retired at age 29. Only last year, Jessica Shuran Yu, a Singaporean figure skater revealed that she, along with other girls in her training club, had been repeatedly physically assaulted by their coaches when she started skating in China. Some kids have to pursue this as a profession because their parents have invested a lot in them, so they get no freedom of choosing their path. However, this is just one half of the problem. The IOC responded to Yus statements, telling the Guardian that it stands together with its athletes, but it did not provide much further elaboration or present any plans to prevent future abuse. I fell in love with figure skating when I was 5, mesmerized by the spins and jumps I watched at the Olympics and by the delicate beauty of the girls and young women in elegant, sparkly dresses. Well, perhaps its because I dont eat them. If you read Ashleys article I think she spoke about this so well. This authority needs to be given the power to investigate such instances of abuse and to punish the perpetrators. But those three are the coaches who supported Peggy Fleming, Evgeni Plushenko and Michelle Kwan memorable skaters with lasting legacies in the sport who never felt discarded or worthless when. Ashley said that we are very far behind in making the sport safe for every young kid who aspires to be a figure skater in the future. The closed nature of their political systems muffles any cries for help. In fact, the law somehow assists these predators to execute their disgusting plans. If anyone wishes to me to add contact details for further organisations, please contact me. But as a Singaporean athlete who trained in China, I feel I am in a unique position.. Coaches obsession with weight has often led skaters to develop eating disorders. She said: There is a toxicity that plagues aesthetic sports like gymnastics and figure skating, which both have environments in which adults can easily exploit young girls with big dreams. However, this is just one half of the problem. So subconsciously you know that speaking out about being hit would ruin this perfectionism., In the past week Yu has contacted the Singapore Ice Skating Association and Singapore Safe Sport to detail her experiences and said she was determined to help protect the next generation of young athletes. Read about our approach to external linking. "A lot of the judges are very conservative people who expect figure skating to be a certain way," says Currie. if(typeof ez_ad_units != 'undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,600],'skateperfect_com-box-4','ezslot_21',109,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-skateperfect_com-box-4-0'); The power imbalances can be due to the age difference, designation, or seniority. A prominent Olympic figure skating coach has been accused of physically abusing skaters including biting a female student during a training session eight years ago, according to a report. I didn't want to be known in figure skating as the athlete who would cause trouble. A day later, he committed suicide. Three-time British bronze medallist Harry Mattick tells a troubling story in one episode about an abusive former coach. Would you really let your teenage daughter spend time with boys/ men 4 years older? Disgraced figure skating coach Richard Callaghan has agreed to not work with minors ever again following the settlement of a lawsuit against him that accused the 76-year-old of sexual abuse in the . Skating fans call this the Eteri Expiration Date. In Sochi, Lipnitskaya was 15 years old, as was Zagitova in Pyeongchang, as is Kamila Valieva right now, in Beijing. Either they competed while injured, or they were replaced. Sports fans want to cheer for winners, and Eteri girls always win. Whereas, three other women accused him of inappropriate actions and sexual abuse. Now 19, Yu said she decided to speak after watching Athlete A, the Netflix documentary detailing sexual abuse in American gymnastics, and reading claims of widespread abuse in British Gymnastics. After many years of suffering from this abuse, Yu decided to come forward and speak out about what many young figure skaters in China have to face. Again in this situation power imbalance is the major cause that allowed it to happen. I remember being completely baffled why he did it, she added. I will also need to lose some weight, something like 3 kilograms, to decrease the risk of injuries, she said before retiring less than a month later. Ms Abitbol, who is now 44, said she was. Athletes and anti-doping chiefs have today blasted Russia for 'abusing' a teenage figure skater after it was revealed she tested positive for a banned heart medication, calling for her trainers. Ms. Abitbol accused her former coach Gilles Beyer of raping her several times from 1990 to 1992, when she was 15 to 17. This is maybe because of the age difference between male and female skaters. Anitbol wants him to be behind bars, wants him to face the punishment of his misconduct and she is hopeful that other victims will also come out during the prosecution against Beyes. if(typeof ez_ad_units != 'undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[320,100],'skateperfect_com-large-mobile-banner-1','ezslot_1',113,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-skateperfect_com-large-mobile-banner-1-0'); Yulia Lipnitskaya, the star of the Sochi 2014 Olympics, came out and stated that the coaching staff of Eteri caused her to develop anorexia. Yu continues: When I was 14 and going through puberty, I started to struggle with my jumps because I was gaining weight. This type of bullying is usually unnoticed. In any case, people who are considered to be less powerful or less authoritative are the victims. Bullying and Abuse in Figure Skating is mentioned numerous times in the article because I want it to stand out for search on the net. The U.S. Center for SafeSport is investigating former Olympic bronze medalist and renowned figure skating coach Peter Oppegard over allegations that include biting and throwing hot beverages. Yu explained that at the time when such incredible abuse was taking place, it was hard to open up to people about what she was facing. Skating is an alluring, attractive, and glamorous world. Lupron, a puberty blocker known to induce menopause, three heart medications: trimetazidine, hypoxen, and L-carnitine. Zimmerman, inducted into . I urge anyone actually affected by the these events to speak out. But in reality, she was forced to be in that lewd situation. We've received your submission. Therefore, parents see this as an opportunity and want their kids to be at the top level all the time which puts them in enormous stress. Women figure skaters are obnoxiously sexualised, to put it mildly. Harassment and abuse is unfortunately part of society and also occurs within sport, it said. The New York Times reported Tuesday that Valieva, a healthy child with no heart conditions, tested positive for three heart medications: trimetazidine, hypoxen, and L-carnitine. Yus accounts carry on throughout her many years she spent in the rink, detailing how harrowing the experience was as she was growing up. Copyright 2007-2023 Khurana And Khurana. You must report any injuries to WFSC representatives, Coaches or rink staff at the time of the event. All the while, the Karolyis were treated as celebrities and heroes, able to mold children into champions. Sand and Meno, coached by Hall of Fame coach John Nicks, skated to . By Rita Wenxin Wang Feb 16, 202210:31 AM Coach Eteri Tutberidze with Kamila Valieva after her. Reviewed in the United States on December 21 . Figure Skating can be best described as a sport in which athletes engage in artistic performances while skating on ice, which include jumps, spins, lifts, intricate footwork, and other freestyle movements. There is no example of the accused being punished severely for what they have done in the past with young kids. Some organizations and authorities take it for granted and this ignorance leads to ruin the entire careers of many young aspiring skaters. Morgan Cipres, French figure skater, a two-times Olympian, is facing a probe by the US police over sexual abuse of a 13-year-old girl in Dec 2017. BEIJING (AP) The coach behind Russia's figure skating dynasty rarely speaks to the media, enhancing her mystique as a guru who produces a line of teenage stars who can land jumps no other women even attempt. You're doing the same thing over and over again, it just doesn't work and you're like, 'why isn't it working?'". Report abuse. They all train with the same coach, Eteri Tutberidze, at a storied rink in Moscow called Sambo-70. Even parents do not put a check and balance to coaches and even to fellow athletes. I was called over and kicked on the bone of my shin with a toe-pick of a blade and made to try again. The International Skating Union has suspended two commentators and launched an investigation after they were caught on air calling one figure skating coach a "bitch," admitted they didn't watch women's figure skating, repeatedly misgendered one competitor, and just generally made asses of themselves. That triple Axel was top notch. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Scandal-scarred figure skater facing four-year Olympic ban, Nathan Chen still hopes US team can celebrate medal after Russian doping scandal, American teen makes figure skating history landing incredible jump, Broken system: Tara Lipinski eviscerates new figure skating age limit, investigation by USA Today Sports and SafeSport reveals. This new bird-flu mutation says no. 2001) or report the incident in writing or verbally to one of the following persons: The ISU Representative for the ISU Event; The Chair of the ISU Medical Commission; The designated ISU Ombudsperson for Harassment and Abuse, currently Ms. Christine Cardis, ISU Anti-Doping Manager (ombudsperson@isu.ch), who will also provide guidance to any individual regarding whether and how to report to the ISU observed or suspected harassment or abuse, in particular of an athlete; If a Skater is involved in the incident: any ISU Athletes Commission member. Wagner, an Olympic bronze medalist, told USA Today that Coughlin assaulted her when both. Thats all. AP Photo/Jae C. Hong A prominent Olympic figure skating coach has been accused of physically abusing skaters including biting. And I genuinely didnt feel like anyone would listen to me anyway. Ex Eteri coached skaters have said, whether you are tired or injured, you still go to the ice and work. There was a point in my life when the abuse made me hate the sport, she said. That is, we just rinsed our mouths and spit it all out. Overbearing mothers, tumultuous partnerships, and abusive coach/skater relations rule many of the elite centers around the world. Peter Oppegard a bronze medal winner at the 1988 US Olympic games and Hall of Famer allegedly bit skater Jessica Pfund, who was 15 at the time, at East West Ice Palace in Artesia, California, after he became furious with her during a practice session in 2013, an investigation by USA Today Sports and SafeSport reveals. I wasnt allowed to limp or cry. Following the Pairs Short Program at the World Figure Skating Championships yesterday The outcome marked a shocking upset: Leading up to the Games, another young Russian skater, 15-year-old Kamila Valieva, had been hyped as the clear favorite and a "once in a lifetime" talent until a failed drug test came to . Harding has repeatedly accused her mother of often being violent towards her growing up, a claim portrayed in the Margot Robbie starring biopic. Pushing ISU as well as National Skating Federations to become a member of WPA and thus, signatory to the Universal Declaration of Players Rights will also add another layer of protection. At Beijing, Lilah Fear and Lewis Gibson, who feature briefly in Freeze, will be representing Team GB as a pair. However, the French Federation of Ice Sports declined to take action against him citing lack of proof. Figure Skating ignored sexual misconduct compl Here Ashley is quoted speaking to USA Today with Christine Brennan. Can I backflip on the ice like flipping my pancake? Work Search: tip: hetalia f/f sort:kudos 1 - 20 of 8,652 Works in Figure Skating RPF. Yu urged the IOC to recognise that young and vulnerable girls in aesthetic sports are particularly at risk. The IOC insisted the safety and wellbeing of athletes was a priority. Rita Wenxin Wang, a writer for Slate Magazine, reported that Russian figure skating coach Eteri Tutberidze subjects athletes to taking puberty blockers, daily public weigh-ins and other abusive measures. if(typeof ez_ad_units != 'undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[320,50],'skateperfect_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_5',108,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-skateperfect_com-medrectangle-4-0');if(typeof ez_ad_units != 'undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[320,50],'skateperfect_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_6',108,'0','1'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-skateperfect_com-medrectangle-4-0_1'); .medrectangle-4-multi-108{border:none !important;display:block !important;float:none !important;line-height:0px;margin-bottom:7px !important;margin-left:auto !important;margin-right:auto !important;margin-top:7px !important;max-width:100% !important;min-height:50px;padding:0;text-align:center !important;}. The Olympics Figure Skating Gala: Who Wore It Better? The age of women skaters is continually declining. Skating is nothing without the talented young athletes who love and support the sport. become a competitive figure skater 9 Steps, How Ice Skaters Spin Fast And Dont get Dizzy, How To Recover From A Figure Skating Injury, How To Protect Your Feet When Ice Skating, What Can Your Competitors Teach You About Skating. Figure skaters have to train so hard to be perfect their diligence is impeccable. Yu said she hoped that with Beijing hosting the Winter Olympics in just over 18 months time, the IOC would recognise it had a unique opportunity to use its influence. "I literally woke up one day and couldn't feel my left leg from the knee down," she explains. Yet are these rules and commitments hailed and pushed out hard for everyone in the sport? Michelle Kwan won five World Championship medals before retiring in her mid-20s. "We train around three to four hours together on the ice, six days a week and then, each day, we probably do about two hours of off-ice as well," Gibson tells BBC Sport. Four other female figure skaters have accused Mr. Beyer and two other. Feb 17, 2022. I even liked him.. "He punched me in the stomach," Mattick recounts, adding, "I remember being in a lot of shock, but thinking, 'well, that's something I can use to leave now'.". Young girls will put on weight as they reach this stage in their life, its natural. Eteri Tutberidze. The approach for tackling bullying and abuse in figure skating is reactive rather than proactive, the victims have to report it otherwise it fades away (but not for the victim). I want the issue to feel real to people, and for them to understand the dynamics of my sport, where uncomfortable power imbalances thrive to this day. His pairs partner, Bridget Namiotka, later stated that he sexually abused her for two years. They sacrifice the most precious part, their childhood, with intense training, strict diet plans, and a very restricted routine. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. No, I dont like chips. I was made to feel so small. And despite Golden's dedication to launching her . But in the age of the quad revolution, such longevity is unthinkable. We encountered an issue signing you up. When theres emphasis on presentation and perfectionism, youre taught to care about how others perceive you, especially by judges who have power over your scores. 2.0 out of 5 stars Cover of Book looks Used and Almost Torn. I didnt want to be known in figure skating as the athlete who would cause trouble. The case has reopened after the police received new information regarding the accused. She alleged she was abused for two years and 9 others were also abused by him. Saturday, 9 October 2021 American Olympic pairs figure skating coach Dalilah Sappenfield has been temporarily prohibited by the US Center for SafeSport from contacting numerous athletes and. I remember thinking this didnt feel right at all and that something might tear.. When shes not writing, shes likely out befriending cats or adventuring along the Pacific coast. Yu said she was regularly hit with a plastic skate guard after she made mistakes and another punishment involved being kicked so hard with the toe-pick of a skate that it bloodied her shin and left a lasting scar. Physical abuse also included being violently kicked with a skate toe-pick which would leave her shins bloodied, marking her with a permanent scar. They do their best to delay puberty by eating only powdered nutrients or by taking Lupron, a puberty blocker known to induce menopause. There is a dark side that is easily camouflaged by the immense fame and perks attached to the sport. After attending a camp in Europe, when he was 15, run by the coach of the best skater in the world at the time, Harry met a high-level Russian coach who offered to train him in America. The last two Olympics cycles show an enhanced emphasis on gravity-defying jumps, and therefore younger girls are being pushed early to the senior arena, for, as Alysa Liu said, once girls hit puberty and start developing muscles, they have to learn to jump all over again. Hes married to estranged wife Karen Kwan, an elite figure skater in the 1990s and the older sister of Michelle Kwan, a five-time world champion who won two Olympic medals. When Pinsent made his remarks, the IOC said it was inappropriate to comment. With Beijing hosting the next Winter Olympics, Yu pointed out that it would be the perfect opportunity for the IOC to act. I like sweetschocolate, candy. Think 'Cheer', but on ice. The only way to pursue my love of the sport was by cheering on my favorites. This is not normal. There are many other types of bully common in figure skating. The third point is, I am still building muscles and stamina, I do feel out of breath when I skate faster. But the bigger story of Russias skating success and how it came about began much earlier. I didnt want to stir the pot. Judges rate the quality of every element in a skaters program on a scale from -5 to +5, as well as mark five different presentation components on a scale from 1 to 10. Power imbalances can be between skaters and coaches, skaters and administrators, and minors to elite skaters. September 11, 5:06 p.m. - The original version of this article stated that Coughlin was an Olympian. Mark Hanretty, a former ice dancer who works as a coach, calls the triple axel, "an absolute prerequisite" for any male who wants to compete at international competition. Figure skaters do not have a reliable safety net. We recommend moving this block and the preceding CSS link to the HEAD of your HTML file. He breaks down his daily routine. Boitano's Edge: Inside The Real World Of Figure Skating . While many joke about this shocking & vengeful incident, scary atmospheres for skaters are real. One of Tutberidzes students, Yulia Lipnitskaya, was a gold-medal favorite in the 2014 Sochi Olympics. In an autobiography released last week, champion figure skater Sarah Abitbol alleged her former coach Gilles Beyer abused her when she was a teenager. I believe there are two reasons for this behavior. The first episode airs at 21:00 GMT on the new BBC Three Channel on Saturday 5 February, with the first four episodes on iPlayer afterwards. This sport is not for the faint-hearted. The Karolyis discovered that pre-pubescent girls, with smaller, lighter bodies, could more easily complete the difficult skills required of elite-level gymnastics. Young skaters are therefore placed on a strict diet, with back to back on-ice and off- ice training schedules to burn calories. The Olympics Hero Who Embodies Why the Games Still Matter, The Dynamic, Superbly Named Event That the Next Winter Olympics Should Add, The Bobsled Decorator Makes the Bobsledders Sled Faster. It was dehumanising.. These relationships extend beyond the typical drama expected in a female-dominated sport, creating a toxic environment for all parties involved. Yu spoke of feeling able to open up because while she had grown up in China and her parents were born there, she competed internationally for Singapore, the country where her father has citizenship. Im one of those fans who knew about Eteri Tutberidzes abuse. Find someone you trust please and regardless of the status of the attacker, expose them. The future looks promising in women's skating. It was dehumanising.. Committees independent of the Skating Federations of the countries can be set up with the authority to investigate and punish perpetrators. Boitano's Edge: Inside The Real World Of Figure Skating [Boitano, Brian, Harper, Suzanne] on Amazon.com. We take a closer look . Those girls were pushed into a brutal training regime and were not allowed to complain about pain, for any reason. In an attempt to adhere to skatings unrealistic expectations, Ive seen many skaters develop eating disorders, endure demeaning relationships with their coaches, and sacrifice their identity to be number one. Tom Graser/Plaindealer . The Eteri girls talk openly about not being able to drink water during competitions. 'It was dehumanising': Jessica Shuran Yu condemns training abuse in China World championship skater describes culture of abuse Urges IOC to better protect skaters before Beijing 2022 Jessica. Valieva's coach Eteri Tutberidze, who is known in skating circles for harsh training methods, faces heightened scrutiny at the Beijing Games. He knew the girl would not have the courage to speak out and if she would report it, no one would believe her. In 2019, another monster, a predator coach Richard Callaghan was banned for life by the US center for Safesport for various sexual abuse but because of the flawed system, his ban was later reduced to three years by an arbitrator who believed that he had no other choice. All rights reserved. Some even achieve this feat as young as 13. Already got the Winter Olympics buzz? I was a young skater coming up through the ranks in a judged sport, Wagner told USA Today Sports. Its similar to those practices experienced in Gymnastics.if(typeof ez_ad_units != 'undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'skateperfect_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_13',119,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-skateperfect_com-medrectangle-3-0'); This dark side is completely ignored by most of the parties because this wickedness occurs during the struggle to becoming a star. Pfund said the bruise lasted for at least a week. Spours speaks about how, as a more muscular athlete than other women, she does not fit the typical mould of a female skater. I dreaded going to practice, wished for car accidents and sobbed through entire training sessions. It shows that Callaghan was so confident that he would get away with it very easily. Search Works. If I had just continued the way I was in Detroit [where she was training at the time], Id probably be dead.. The silver medalist pledged never to skate . But a name can shape so much of how my story is perceived. Three years later, it all could have been over. Romaine Haguenauer, an Olympic coach for France who operates out of Montreal, "We have been saying that she is very tough with her students. Others try to thread the needle of supporting her skaters without supporting her. While United States Figure Skating officials advised SafeSport to complete the investigation, SafeSport removed the notification of his suspension from its website and there has been no news about the investigation since. Yu shared that not only were these trainers rough they were incredibly abusive. Setting up independent committees and panels facilitating reporting and investigating infringement of rights mentioned in this Declaration, and giving them the power to accord proportionate penalty will serve to provide another means of protection to female figure skaters. People like Gilles Beyer are so used to doing such things that Sarah was just another victim for him and never cared what would happen next. A former competitive figure skater on Monday filed a $10 million lawsuit against one of the sport's most celebrated coaches, accusing him of sexual abuse that dates back to the 1970s. who no longer skates competitively, credited the #MeToo movement and Coughlins suspension as her reasons for coming forward now after completely blocking out the alleged assault, during which she said, I was absolutely paralyzed in fear. She did not come forward immediately partly because I was a young skater coming up through the ranks in a judged sport. Morgan Cipres, French figure skater, a two-times Olympian, is facing a probe by the US police over sexual abuse of a 13-year-old girl in Dec 2017. Ashley is a freelance writer, starry-eyed poet, and wandering druid. ", Another skater adds, "Everyone knows someone who's had a near-fatal accident on the ice.". Figure skaters either compete as singles or in mixed-sex pairs. Training in China since she was a young girl, Yu has been brought up under the tutelage of cut-throat Chinese trainers. Skaters are going through a remarkable amount of stress and pressure all the time and they do not know how to deal with it. Younger girls are entering the senior arena today, as compared to the late 20th century. Why too did Bridget Namiotka, another accuser, mention him four months after? The abuse started from the age of 11 when I started being told to reach out a hand whenever I made mistakes, she said. Furthermore, the World Players Association also came up with a Universal Declaration of Players Rights in 2019 as an endeavour to extend fundamental human rights to athletes and sportspersons. Policy Questions & Abuse . Ashley Wagner was so terrified by the behavior that she did not have any idea what to do and was hoping that John would stop soon and would leave. Valieva is suspected of failing a doping test and could see her Olympics dreams dashed. Craig Maurizi, the former skater turned Olympic coach who first reported the allegations to SafeSport, declined to comment, but his attorney Ilene Jaroslaw of the New York-based firm Phillips Nizer LLP said the decision calls the credibility of the U.S. Center for SafeSport, which has exclusive jurisdiction over allegations of sexual misconduct At this age, young skaters have no idea how to react and they usually keep everything inside, and never speak out about bullies and lewd things happen to them. Coach Yebin Mok says: "It's very, very common to have a mental block. There is hardly anyone who does not experience it, especially the female athletes during the span of their career. I love to ice skate for fun and yet started with inline skating when younger. Btw autotranslator gave me only Yuzu and Mura from all men I was, you can say, not drinking water at all. Figure skaters usually come into the limelight at a very young age, they compete at the junior level when they are around 10, 11 years old, and at the elite level at the age of 15, 16.
Shriners Hospital Kid Kaleb Age,
Cambridge Offer Holders 2021 Student Room,
How To Insert Wheel Of Names In Powerpoint,
Can We Wear Feroza In Left Hand,
Articles A
No comments.